The Global Wellness Institute and Scientific American Worldview recently joined forces on a roundtable called 'The Science of Wellnessâ€"Hype or Hope?'Â
The amazing lineup of participants (from top doctors to major media) took part in an equally amazing conversation and together they identified 10 things that need to happen now to create a healthier world.
Not only do we need simple, provocative public marketing campaigns around obesity and sedentary lifestyles (like the successful anti-smokingÂ campaignsÂ of the 20th century), but we need an intense focus on behavioral psychology to BEGIN to identify a â€śscience of lifestyle changeâ€ť for a world that's just getting fatter and sicker by the day.
Global Wellness Institute and Scientific American Worldview
Hold Roundtable on the â€śScience of Wellnessâ€ť
Leaders who gathered called for: simple, provocative public health messages that could do for obesity what anti-smoking campaigns accomplished; a more intense focus on the behavioral sciences to identify strategies that could better support lifestyle change; and more medical studies on wellness approaches.
The Global Wellness Instituteâ„˘ (GWI) in partnership with Scientific American Worldview recently held an invitation-only roundtable on the topic of â€śThe Science of Wellness: Hype or Hope?â€ť Leaders from the medical, science, business, technology, research, media, workplace wellness and hotel/spa worlds gathered on February 11 at theÂ Everyday HealthÂ headquarters in Manhattan for a wide-ranging conversation on the many ways that science and evidence-based medicine are impacting the wellness industry, and how wellness (and the growing medical evidence for wellness approaches) is impacting people, traditional medicine, private companies and public policy.
The discussion, co-moderated by Jeremy Abbate, VP, Global Media Alliances, Scientific American;Â Publishing Director, Scientific American Worldview and Susie Ellis, president and CEO of the GWI, included executives and experts from American Public Media, Cornell and Rutgers Universities, Delos, Everyday Health, The International Heart and Lung Institute Center for Restorative Medicine, Optum, Paramedical Consultants, Inc. (PCI), Patients Beyond Borders, Pegasus Capital Advisors, Six Senses, SRI International and Viacom Media Networks.
The leaders assembled identified numerous best steps forward to build a healthier world: from the need for powerful public health marketing campaigns around obesity and sedentary lifestyles - to a much more intense focus on cognitive/behavioral psychology to identify a â€śscience of lifestyle changeâ€ť for a world getting fatter and sicker â€" to a call for more (and more appropriately designed) clinical trials on wellness approaches.
Top Ten Recommendations - Experts gathered argued we needâ€¦
Simple, Provocative Public Wellness Campaigns:Â Some of the biggest â€śwellness successesâ€ť of the last century have involved powerful marketing messages (like the anti-smoking, â€śstop littering,â€ť or â€śwear seatbeltsâ€ť campaigns of the 20th century â€" or more recent ads visualizing how many packets of sugar reside in a can of soda). We need new health campaigns and public service announcements around weight loss/obesity and sedentary lifestyles that are simple, inspiring and are repeated over and over.
More Behavioral Sciences Research to Create a â€śScience of Lifestyle Changeâ€ť:Â While medical research on the benefits of wellness approaches grabs headlines, the key to healthy populations is to begin to crack the code on helping people start, and sustain, lifestyle change. We know so little, and a more intense focus on, and new research in, the behavioral sciences and cognitive psychology (from brain plasticity to choice architecture) is critical if we ever want to create an evidence-based â€śscience of lifestyle change and willpower.â€ť
More, better-funded studies on wellness approaches:Â Clinical studies on wellness approaches represent theÂ under-resourced â€śDavidâ€ť to Big Pharmaâ€™s â€śGoliathâ€ť. Average R&D costs for a new drug have reached $2.9 billion,* while funds for wellness clinical trials are drastically less (often under $100,000) â€" and the GWI estimates that (Stage 3) drug trials have around 100 times the participants: roughly 50 for a wellness study, vs. 4,000 for a drug trial. Without more, better-funded trials, highly respected medical organizations likeÂ CochraneÂ will continue to withhold positive recommendations in their meta-reviews on practices like meditation or yoga, even when thereâ€™s positive, preliminary evidence.
A Better Understanding of â€" and More Appropriately Designed - Wellness Studies:Â Clinical trials on wellness approaches often have unique qualities, and superimposing the double-blind model can be likeÂ fitting an â€śapple into an orange.â€ťÂ Placebo models donâ€™t work when participants know theyâ€™re experiencing things like meditation or exercise, and wellness approaches often involve practitioners, so canâ€™t be uniformly replicated (or regulated) like a pill. Short studies fail to capture the most meaningful outcomes for long-term, prevention-focused approaches, and all personalized medicines, like TCM and Ayurveda, defy the randomized trial model entirely. Another problem: most current studies on wellness approaches are performed on sick people (in the hospital setting), providing a limited view of their efficacy. Greater openness to analyzing (and valuing) outcomes from studies that canâ€™t fit perfectly into double blind, or even randomized, trial designs is needed.
Doctors to Expand Their Understanding of the Wellness Concept & Consult the Evidence: Despite growth in integrative medicine, the medical experts at the roundtable agreed that the vast majority of physicians still narrowly equate â€śwellnessâ€ť with testing (i.e., mammograms, osteoporosis checks, etc.), at which point the prevention â€śboatâ€ť has often already sailed. And while almost all doctors turn to evidence-based medicine databases to evaluate courses of treatment, â€śalmost noneâ€ť consult those databases for studies on wellness approaches - and the lionâ€™s share of their required continuing medical education comes via drug companies. Medical systems, insurers and policy-makers must support more physician education around â€" and the â€śprescribingâ€ť of â€" wellness approaches like diet change, exercise, etc.
More Media Responsibility in Communicating Wellness Info: If people are unlikely to get much wellness information from doctors, theyâ€™re devouring it at media/digital channels, where thereâ€™s an explosion of reporting on the latest wellness studies and â€śmiracleâ€ť breakthroughs. The rise of digital has been a double-edged sword: empowering people with unprecedented sources of health information (Google just reported that one in twenty searches is health-related), but also confusing them with contradictory, often un-contextualized new findings. More media responsibility, and more peer reviewing and curation of wellness studies by medical professionals, is needed.
To Stop Putting Wellness in the â€śAlternative Medicineâ€ť Bracket, If We Want to Serve Millennials: Entrenched healthcare systems and older generations have viewed medicine and wellness as separate, even antagonistic, domains, but the millennial generation (and younger) views health very holistically, where wellness, diet and exercise are not â€śalternative,â€ť but key pieces in a total health puzzle. Medical systems and marketers that want to reach younger generations need to embrace that new reality.
To Recognize That Private Companies Are Often Leading in Applying Science to Wellness: Wellness is a $3.4 trillion,** consumer-driven market, and itâ€™s private companies and public-private partnerships that are applying science to new wellness concepts the most creatively: from Delos building a lab with the Mayo Clinic to test and develop new â€śhealthy for humansâ€ť features for the spaces people live and work in -Â to companies like Lighting Science creating healthy, nature-based lighting technologies - to new, billion-dollar â€śhealthy citiesâ€ť being developed globally, incorporating hospitals, education and every aspect of healthy living.
Workplace Wellness to Move Beyond Generic ROI Reporting and Focus on Culture Change: Companies are adopting workplace wellness programs at an explosive rate, but so many things are holding them back: from an obsession with ROI reporting that doesnâ€™t measure results/returns against specific program components, to new signs that employee wellness is devolving into a â€śhave/have notâ€ť situation. For instance, top executives may be embracing meditation at the World Economic Forum, but companies are increasingly profiting from penalties exacted from the most program resistant/high-risk workers. Successful workplace wellness initiatives must think beyond the â€śprogramâ€ť and focus on honest, top-to-bottom culture change.
Governments to Grasp That Health Is Wealth:Â Policymakers often perceiveÂ â€śwellnessâ€ť as a matter of individual decisions and wellbeing, butÂ the physical and mental healthÂ of national populations will increasingly decide national economic and political power. Countries focusing on prevention, and who can get healthcare spending under 10% of GDP, will increasingly have a global advantage.
- Jeremy Abbate, VP, Global Media Alliances, Scientific American;Â Publishing Director, Scientific American Worldview
- Dr. Brandon Alderman, Professor, Department of Exercise Science and Sport Studies, Rutgers University
- David Brancaccio, Host,Â American Public Media's â€śMarketplace Morning Reportâ€ť (NPR)
- Anna Bjurstam, VP of Spas and Wellness, Six Senses Hotels Resorts Spas; Owner,Â Raison d'EtreÂ
- Alfredo Carvajal,Â President,Â Delos International and Signature Programs, Delos
- Susie Ellis, Chairman and CEO, Global Wellness Institute
- Dr. Steven Gundry, Director, The International Heart and Lung Institute Center for Restorative Medicine
- Anne Hubert, Senior Vice President, Viacom Media Networks
- Neil JacobsÂ CEO, Six Senses Hotels Resorts SpasÂ
- Katherine Johnston, Senior Economist, SRI InternationalDr. Nazlie Latefi, Chief Scientific Officer, Pegasus Capital Advisors
- Clare Martorana, EVP and General Manager - Consumer Health and Wellness, Everyday Health
- Beth McGroarty, Director of Research, Global Wellness InstituteÂ
- Mim Senft, Wellness Director, Plus One Health Management, Optum
- Mary Tabacchi, PhD,Â Professor, Cornell University
- Susanne Warfield, CEO, Paramedical Consultants, Inc. (PCI)
- Josef Woodman, CEO, Patients Beyond BordersÂ
- Ophelia Yeung, Senior Consultant, SRI International
Everyday Health donated its boardroom for the discussion. Lunch was provided byÂ EXKi, a fair-trade certified, upscale, â€śquick-casual" restaurant that focuses on locally sourced, organic ingredients.
To learn moreÂ about the GWIâ€™s roundtables, or the organizationâ€™s 2015 Global Wellness Summit being held in Mexico City from November 13-15, contact Beth McGroarty: email@example.com or (+1) 213.300.0107
Â *The Tufts Center for the Study of Drug Development, 11/2014
** Global Wellness Institute, â€śGlobal Spa & Wellness Economy Monitor,â€ť 2014